Tuesday, September 27, 2016

Political satire seems unstoppable for Emmy variety honors

No Emmy award in history has been as dominated as the award for Outstanding Variety Series has in the past 14 years. Jon Stewart and his family tree of political satirists have won the last 14 Emmys in this category as well as 13 of the last 14 for Outstanding Writing for a Variety Series (Emmys). Their brand of political satire showed such a firm grip on the category that in 2015 the Academy split it into two awards to give other shows a chance, according to the LA Times.

The Stewart Streak
            After being nominated in 2001 and 2002, The Daily Show won its first Outstanding Variety Series Emmy in 2003 (it won Outstanding Writing for a Variety Series in 2001). For the next decade, eleven other shows received nominations, but The Daily Show never lost. The streak is the longest winning streak for a television show in Emmy Award history (Emmys).

The Colbert Report
            Of the eleven shows that challenged The Daily Show from 2003-2012 only two were political (Real Time with Bill Maher and The Colbert Report). Late night entertainment shows like those of Jay Leno, David Letterman and Conan O’Brien took a healthy share of the nominations (52 percent during Stewart’s run).
When Stewart finally relinquished his hold on the Award, it was to his former Daily Show correspondent  Stephen Colbert. Despite a playful on-screen rivalry over the award, Stewart was an executive producer of The Colbert Report and the award stayed in the Comedy Central family. Colbert would win back-to-back Emmys before conceding to Stewart in 2015, the final year of both of their shows.

Talk vs. Sketch
            Starting in 2015, after more than a decade of political satire ion, the Academy decided to split it in two. According to the LA Times, “the variety series was split in two so ‘Real Time with Bill Maher’ didn’t have to compete with ‘Drunk History.’” With two new categories

·      “Outstanding Variety Talk Series”
·      “Outstanding Variety Sketch Series”

shows like “Inside Amy Schumer” (2015 sketch winner) and “Key and Peele” (2016) could compete with more similar peers for recognition.

Post-Stewart/Colbert
With the two shows that owned the Emmy gone, the others were looking at their best chance this century of taking home a trophy. But, it should come as no surprise that the award stayed in the Stewart family of satire. The award went to “Last Week Tonight with John Oliver” on HBO. Oliver, like Colbert, is a former Daily Show correspondent. Oliver also hosted the Daily Show for eight weeks during the summer of 2013 while Jon Stewart directed his film “Rosewater.”
            While the Comedy Central run may be over, and it looks that way with Trevor Noah being snubbed and Larry Wilmore getting canceled, there’s no doubt that political satire is the variety show of choice for the academy.

Learn More:

By Cal Mincer

0 comments:

Post a Comment